Wednesday, 28 March 2012

Empire Day



In the course of the 20th century, Britain underwent two world wars which decimated its young manhood, devastated its cities and bankrupted its economy.  It lost the most extensive empire the world has ever known, and almost the entire manufacturing base on which its wealth and expansionist zeal was predicated.  Despite this (and its diminutive size) it is still the world’s seventh largest economy by GDP. Extraordinary, when you think about it.  And even more extraordinary that this loss of power and relative wealth was a largely post-war phenomenon: in a few brief decades, the work of two or three centuries was undone; and Britons found themselves being invited to atone for their former global destiny and to get used to being just another country.

Against this background, any attempt to re-appraise the legacy of the British Empire is a risky enterprise.  Children of my mother’s, inter-war, generation were raised to see the Empire as a Jolly Good and Necessary Thing, and the British as a sort of chosen race, destined to bring civilisation, Sung Evensong, and a proper cup of tea to the earth.  While my father (whom she would not meet until 1948) was growing up in 1930s British India, she was at school in east London where, on Empire Day (24 May) they waved union jacks and sang:

Red, white and blue
What does it mean to you?
Surely you're proud
Shout it aloud
Britons awake!
The Empire too
We can depend on you.
Freedom remains
These are the chains
Nothing can break.

Well, they may not have broken, but clearly they do not bind in the same way. This is the theme of Jeremy Paxman's BBC TV series, Empire.  In it, Paxo visits various Commonwealth countries - apparently wearing the same powder-blue linen shirt throughout - in an attempt to re-assess the British Empire's legacy.  The tone and content is one designed to avoid any charge of revisionism on the one hand, and mindless 1970s-style repudiation on the other.  It doesn't quite achieve objectivity, perhaps because that is not really possible, and the series is in any case billed as a personal account.  But there is evidence of an honest determination to get at the facts, combined with Paxman's celebrated "come off it" inquisitorial style designed to get people to spit out what they actually think.

He is, for instance, able to ask an east African man of Asian race (whose forbears were effectively transplanted by the British) if he is not grateful to the British for building the trans-Africa railway which he so admires; and also to ask an Indian if she does not hate the British for their cruelty and snobbery.  The answers are typically nuanced, and can be summarised as "yeah but no but". The conclusion that the viewer is invited to draw is that the British Empire was in some senses a very good thing, and in other senses a rather horrible one.  Not very exciting or ground-breaking; but perhaps in need of being said.

The late, great Bernard Levin coined the term "The Fallacy of the Altered Standpoint", to describe the difficulty of judging something - particularly a historical event or circumstance - free of the insidious prejudices imparted by subsequent events and subtle changes in social mores.  This applies rather sharply to post-war attitudes concerning the British Empire, which have been conditioned by Britain's radically (and, in historical terms, rapidly) changed status.  Perhaps the relatively balanced take espoused by Empire is a small sign that we are beginning to shake off our post-war, post-imperial shroud of self-denigration, and to view our historical selves both more kindly and objectively.

History is neither good not bad. It just is.

Tuesday, 13 March 2012

The NHS and Me


There is a poster in the window of the office of the attendants (they would be called concierges in more westerly postal districts) who look after me and the other residents of my City apartment block: "SAVE OUR NHS" it screams in a huge cerise font.


Now, I am a very child of the NHS: born in 1953, I was delivered by said service in east London (I could almost have been a Call the Midwife baby) and enveloped by it from both my and its earliest days.  It tended to my childhood ailments (often involving a GP's home visit), routinely tested my ears and eyes, inspected my feet and drilled my teeth.  It inoculated me against various diseases, the names of some of which - probably partly because of its existence - are rarely heard these days. It gave my mother concentrated orange juice for me to drink and - less welcome - cod-liver oil to swallow.  It even gave me my very own number which - though long since superseded by one with 10 digits - I remember to this day: MMQS 439.  And, notwithstanding the occasional recourse to private treatment, eg for slipped discs (believe me the physiotherapy's no less painful because you're paying for it), it is the NHS on which I continue to rely - quite heavily - to keep me healthy.  I am 58, not rich, and have had lifelong access to free basic healthcare.  My personal experience of a widish variety of hospital and specialist care has been variable but, on balance, positive.  I am, if you like, almost a walking testimonial for the comprehensive, free-at-the-point-of-use, cradle-to-grave care provided by the NHS.  I have as much reason to be sentimental about it as anyone.


And yet sentimental about it I am not. Someone has said that the NHS is the nearest thing we have to a national religion and, depressing as that is, it does perhaps help to explain the reaction to the Health Bill currently going through Parliament.  Some of this borders on the hysterical, and can be readily disregarded. Some is fairly crude political opportunism, and can be received accordingly.  Other criticism is more measured and/or more independent; and it makes sense to heed the reservations of those who actually work in the NHS, and on whom people like me depend for our care.  But there's no doubting the emotion involved.  I wonder if the proposed dismantling of the Church of England (which is our actual national religion) would provoke such passion?


I use the word "dismantling" because that is the word used repeatedly by its critics to summarise the present Government's intention with regard to the NHS; and it is that fear which is undoubtedly exciting much of the reaction.  I do not claim to have more than a layman's insight into it, but it seems to me that nothing like "dismantling" is actually on the cards.  Of the two main provisions, one (the extension of competition) is not on the face of it very controversial.  Competition within the NHS was introduced under Thatcherism and significantly extended under New Labour.  Some are and have been, perfectly rationally, opposed to it all along; but it is now, in one form or another, a reality of at least some aspects of almost of all public services. It's reasonable to question the extent of its influence, but a bit anachronistic to recoil in horror from the very idea.


The second of the two main provisions - the concentration of power and money in the hands of GPs - is a big change.  Who knows - it may well not work.  But does it constitute the dismantling of the entire structure?  I doubt it.  In fact the more you look at the Bill, the less radical it all seems; and I'm beginning to wonder if that's the real issue.


You see, if you treat the NHS less like a religion and more like any other taxpayer-funded service; if you can appreciate its strengths but admit its shortcomings; if you can be honest about your experience within it it while being realistic about what it can deliver in its present form, you may begin to think that nobody is being radical enough.  In the last 15 years, overall spending on the NHS has more than trebled - and even now, is continuing to rise slightly.  It's true that the rate of increase is now falling well behind increasing costs (which is why "net" cuts are necessary). But I cannot be the only NHS user on whom it has dawned that the recent massive increase in spending has still not given us the health service we want (ie one free of horror stories of the kind that pre-occupy the early evening news bulletins).  I cannot be the only NHS user who has observed that, satisfactory though my overall health care is, there are some things badly amiss with the NHS that do not seem to be susceptible to increased funding. Have you ever spent a night in an A&E unit? Have you ever been with a loved one during a serious health emergency and extended hospital stay? Have you tried to co-ordinate post-operative care when the hospital and the community health service don't appear able to talk to one another, and you are exhausted?  And, if so, are you still of the opinion that what is needed is simply increased funding?


I don't pretend to know what the answer is.  But I have a growing conviction that what is wrong is with the NHS is embedded in its very culture, which no amount of mere reform (or money) can hope to change.  This culture is one which bears little resemblance to that which existed when I was a child, and which instinct leads me to associate with the gradual disappearance of a certain sort of health professional driven primarily by vocation - this itself perhaps the result of wider social change.  I don't think the re-introduction of Hattie Jacques-style matrons - which some prescribe - would work.  Such people, and those whom they managed and mothered, simply do not exist any more.


This leads me to suspect that what we need is a completely new health service for a new society.  This means actually dismantling the NHS and replacing it with something else - perhaps something closer to the universally admired French system.  Now that would take political courage.



Tuesday, 28 February 2012

Ash Wednesday


In the sitting room of my flat is a lime-green balloon with a smiley face.  It is gas-filled and weighted with a plastic disc which sits on the coffee table, so that the balloon floats just below the ceiling, turning very slowly in the otherwise undetectable eddies generated by the mildly overheated atmosphere.  Sometimes the balloon is smiling out of the window at the City beyond, sometimes it is smiling at me, gormlessly. It twists noiselessly on its tether.

The balloon came in a cardboard box which also contained a small basket of fruit, some of which has since been consumed.  They were gifts from a kind parishioner to my friend and vicar of my parish who is staying with me.  He is staying with me because, three weeks ago tonight, he had an Acute Myocardial Infarction (what we used to call a heart attack) while alone in his vicarage.  An ambulance was called and he was taken to hospital where he was observed, stabilised and investigated, and subsequently underwent what medical folk call a cabbage (CABG - Coronary Artery Bypass Graft).  Although he has never smoked, is quite thin, and had an apparently fairly healthy lifestyle, the bloodflow through three of his coronary arteries had become restricted.  A cabbage was the only solution if he was to avoid further heart attacks and possibly an early death.  In a 5-hour operation, they took two veins out of his legs, stopped his heart, and grafted the veins on to it, bypassing the restricted arteries and restoring a full bloodflow to his heart.  A small miracle.

He was discharged from hospital on Ash Wednesday which dawned, well, ashen.  A typical English day in late winter.  Blank, off-white nimbo-stratus covered the sky without a chink from horizon to horizon as I helped him slowly and carefully down the steps of the hospital and into the streets of east London - he, like someone emerging from a space-craft into the strange, blinding light of a new planet.  He looked, well, ashen. I eventually saw and hailed a taxi, and we got back to my apartment block.  We entered via the car park.  

Now, in the Barbican, the common areas have what I always think of as a rather brave, uncompromising Mitteleuropa character, reminiscent of the continental estates on which I believe they were modelled.  Between the car park and the lift lobby is a strange sort of antechamber.  This small space has two steel and plate-glass doors, a tiled floor, and a grid in the ceiling which admits air and, inevitably, a certain amount of dust and leaf-litter from the walkway above. It is lit by a single, wall-mounted fluorescent light. If you come in this way, you open the first door with your key, and then the second (which does not need a key) and you're in the lift lobby.  The doors bang securely and satisfyingly behind you. Five seconds max. It's a functional space (though its precise function is unclear) and not one in which you linger.  

On this Ash Wednesday, we got inside the first door, and he asked if we could pause for a moment for a rest.  He rested his back against the wall - which he promptly slid down so that he was sitting on the floor, then keeled over, blocking the outer door.  His face was so pale as to appear almost colourless.  There seemed to be no breath or pulse.  I could not open the door to alert the attendant outside, and fumbled for my phone to dial 999.  "Please, God", I prayed, "don't let him die here - not in this hard, cold, comfortless place." I could hear unconcerned voices and footsteps from the walkway above, and a dead leaf skittered on the tiled floor.  For the life of me, I could not think of any of the proper prayers for the dying.  I felt utterly without power or resource. I wondered, uselessly, why, of all the places in which it might have happened - an Umbrian hilltop, a friendly bar in midtown Manhattan, the sanctuary of our own church - a chilly, dusty, pointless no-man's-land of a cell should be this priest's point of departure from the world.  I felt a tear roll down my cheek.  

Then he stirred.  Still deathly pale, he opened his eyes and smiled weakly. "What happened?" he asked.  "You must have passed out. But I thought you'd died."  "When I do die" he said, "I hope it's like that.  It was rather peaceful."

Thursday, 9 February 2012

On Women Bishops

My introduction to education was via a tiny infants school set among the soft wooded hills and babbling brooks of mid-Surrey. In this idyll I was taken daily to school by my mum along with another boy and his mum who lived in the same road.  The boy's name was Michael and his dad was a policeman.  He was my best friend, and we would stand in his back garden waving to the drivers of the (steam) trains which ran behind his house.  They would usually wave back, and we both wanted to be train drivers when we grew up.

Except, weirdly, we both grew up to be civil servants.  Even more weirdly, we ended up in the same government department, and thirty years after our train-waving days, in the same division of the same department.  Michael was cleverer than me, and more senior. He was also rather handsome, popular, and of a lively disposition.  A bit of an all-round golden boy, destined for success.

One of the things the British civil service does well is what it calls policy development.  The government of the day sets out its aims in a particular policy area, and the departmental officials set about translating those aims into proposed legislation and/or whatever else is needed to give them practical effect.  They do this by analysis, discussion and consultation; by identifying "rocks in the water" and developing ways of avoiding them; and by refining, clarifying, and finessing the proposals so that they meet the political intention while minimising disruption and such negative consequences as can be practically minimised.  Much of this process takes place at meetings in which ideas are thrashed out, suggested ways forward are scrutinised, and the advice of professional staff (eg lawyers, engineers, economists, doctors) is taken.  The decision eventually reached is thus the result of thorough examination and reflection; and those involved in implementing it - even if they do not agree with it - have been involved in its development and understand why they are doing it.  They have not necessarily abandoned their own views; but they accept the decision as having been properly made and, in the interests of their department's success and reputation, devote their energies to making it work.

Michael was involved in many of these meetings; and was good at promoting his view and adpating his thinking when confronted with differing ideas and objections.  On one occasion, however, he was so convinced he was right about how to implement some policy, that he refused to compromise.  As the necessary series of meetings progressed, and although most of them thought he was wrong, his colleagues did their best to accommodate him, and to find ways of meeting his objections to opposing ideas.  But he would not budge.  Eventually, as the group's thinking coalesced and broad agreement reached, he found himself in a minority of one.  Still he would not give in.  Everyone continued to be very polite about it, and to acknowledge the integrity of his position.  But his obstinacy reached a point at which it was preventing progress, and the senior official in the group was obliged, reluctantly, to overrule him.  "Michael", he said, " you are a very bright young man, and I predict you will go far.  But you must learn to recognise the point at which you have lost an argument."



Wednesday, 25 January 2012

Choose your scandal

What constitues a moral scandal?  I only ask because of the debate which grew out of yesterday's Government defeat in the Lords on the proposed benefit cap.  The charge was led by the Lords Spiritual, who with the unexpected and opportunistic help of Labour and the opposition of some Liberal Democrats, managed to prevent Child Benefit from being taken into account when the cap is calculated.  Although the Government is likely to try to reverse this when the Welfare Bill comes back to the Commons, the Bishops were momentarily and unusually hailed as heroes by those who oppose the cap, the Coaltion, and all its detestable enormities.  One commentator said that it was the best publicity the CofE had got since the Royal wedding.  Well, it was certainly the most publicity it had got since then; but how good it was depends on what it yields in terms of the Church's public standing. Opinions on this may differ.  And sure enough, differ at least one of them did this morning, in the form of an article by Lord Carey in the unspeakable Daily Mail.  In it, the former ABC criticises (in fairly reasoned terms, it must be said) the Bishops' opposition to the Government's proposals on the grounds that he couldn't "possibly believe prolonging our culture of welfare dependency is in the best interests of our children"; and that "the sheer scale of our public debt... is the greatest moral scandal facing Britain today".

This did not go down well Churchside.  It was a bit disloyal to start with; but worse, it took the shine off what had looked like a much-needed clear win for the Church and those who oppose the Welfare Bill and the Coalition generally.  Now while I have to confess myself not the former Archbishop's greatest admirer, I do think he has a point - our huge public debt is indeed scandalous, it cannot be blamed entirely on bankers, and is at the root of a lot of other unwelcome measures - of which the benefit cap is, partly, one.  And while he might have mentioned a few other contributory scandals - eg the sheer greed of some people inside the banks and elsewhere - to rubbish his view quite as comprehensively as some have done today, strikes me as both unfair and an over-reaction.

But it has led to some interesting discussion about what constitutes a moral scandal.  There are a good few to choose from at the moment.  Phone hacking, bankers' bonuses, MPs' expenses, gay bishops, abortion advertising, and assisted dying are among them.  We all have our favourites.  But all these issues involve our being scandalised by others, safe in our own moral fastnesses.  Is there anything closer to home? No? Sure?


A colleague confessed that he was recently very badly affected by a visit to his elderly mother who is in care, suffering from Parkinson's and Alzheimer's.  While she is ill and confused, she is being looked after perfectly well.  Pretty much everything that can be done for her is being done.  The moral scandal for him is our (including his own) failure to care for our own elderly and infirm as he perceives we used to, and as some cultures still do (even here). He is her only relative; he was moved and upset by her condition, and conscious that, despite the best comfort that could be provided, despite the presence of carers and neighbours, she was utterly alone.  Because that is what we do with mad, ill, old people. 


Phone hacking, did you say?







Monday, 16 January 2012

The Opera Lady




She sits at the bar of Il Mare restaurant on Amsterdam Avenue. It is a Friday night and the place is heaving. Customers enter from the freezing night and wait for a table in a huddle by the doorway. The heater over the door sends waves of ludicrously hot air that just prevent the cold from encroaching as far as her favoured spot. She sips white wine, chatting occasionally, and with the insouciant and proprietorial air of a regular, to the barista. "D'you wanna order now, before it gets even loonier?" asks the latter solicitously. "No: I don't know what I want yet", she replies, with the certainty of the born-again client in New York City. The girl retires, not hurt but put in her place, to wait on the demands of others, less regular but no less demanding. She works flat-out, 7 evenings a week and smiles for America.

The lady is called Elsie and this is her local. She tells us she eats here three evenings a week because she lives alone. She is, in a smallish way, an heiress. Her parents died and left her and her younger brother $1m dollars each. He has spent his on a series of girlfriends and a home on the coast of South Carolina; she has been more frugal. She occupies a rent-stabilised apartment on the Upper West Side, which costs her so little that she can live perfectly comfortably, eating out as she chooses, without eating into her inheritance. She's now 65, but had a career as an operatic agent, working with singers who performed at the world's most famous opera-houses. Given our shared English ancestry, she refers particularly to her visits to Covent Garden and the Coliseum (and doesn't understand why you can't get a post-performance dinner at 11:00pm in London as you can in New York).

We talk about food and drink, and she eats her pasta. She does not look especially as though she needs to lose weight, and sniffs at my explanation of the three Ps avoided by Italian women (pasta, patatas, postre) as the key to minimising weight-gain in later life. I don't mention the fourth no-no - alcohol - as the barista pours her a third glass. Like so many New Yorkers, she doesn't assume from our accents that we are not resident; but when we confess our nationality, chats amiably about the Royal Family. She is interested in actresses who have played the Queen, but struggles to believe there is one who rejoices in the name of Prunella Scales. "Prunella!", she exclaims, "Can you imagine how a child with that name would fare at elementary school in this city?" But, we reflect silently, she was not at school here and is a famous actress. It occurs to me that Elsie must have represented some artists with equally improbable names - some, perhaps, who grew up in New York.

She finishes her meal, then accepts and quickly swallows a glass for the road. She bids us good-night with old-fashioned grace, and leaves when we do, wrapping herself tightly against the bitter Manhattan night.


- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad

Friday, 13 January 2012

Looking West

Dawn, Friday 13 January 2012





It is mid-January on the Upper West Side, but not as cold as I have known it. The dawn rises grey and damp. From my 22nd floor window, I look beyond the nearer water-towers and fire-escapes, across the Hudson River to its farther shore and the slowly blinking red lights of radio masts, beyond shadowy, sleeping New Jersey suburbs, to the line of low hills on the horizon. Ragged clouds scud northwards. The first, brief shaft of weak sunlight catches the tower blocks and roof-gardens. There is a time of day when even the most sanguine are at a low ebb; and The City That Never Sleeps, possibly the most positive place on earth, seems drowsy and may have indeed slept and woken with the tiniest hint of depression.

In the street below, the huge trucks and taxis move warily down Broadway, past boxes stacked high on the sidewalk outside the Fairway supermarket. Like No Other Market, it is a warren-like Aladdin's cave of chaotic plenty: uneven floors, impossibly narrow aisles, clashing trolleys and baskets, incredible amounts of food piled obscenely high and sold... well, not that cheap; all bathed in a complicated scent of coffee and fish with an underlying spicy sweetness. Almost none of the vast amount of fresh produce is sourced outside the USA - this is a nation which can feed itself.

It is January: most of the Christmas lights have gone and the trees are bare - the grey, early hours of the new year. And there are signs of economic slowdown I have not seen before in the years I have been coming here. Filene's Basement is history. This famous chain of stores selling high-end clothes at knock-down prices in almost jumble-sale style has gone forever. There is the occasional closed-up shop unit and vacant lot along Broadway; and a subtle dulling of the exuberance that makes this city so exhilarating for the visitor. The can-do, right-now spirit is in the tap water; it will always survive. But it is temporarily toned down as Gotham, self-styled capital of the Western world, peers into the distance and waits for the recovery.

Tuesday, 13 December 2011

A Moment of Weakness


"Are you allowed to wear that?" the man asked me mock-conspiratorially in a broadish east Belfast accent, indicating the tiny silver cross on my lapel. "I'm a believer", he assured me solemnly.  Now the silly part of me (and I realise I am quite silly, really) wanted to reply "I couldn't leave her if I tried" completing the chorus of the 1966 Monkees hit.  But I didn't, because sillness was not, well... indicated.  You see I was hanging around in the very busy men's toilet on the second floor of John Lewis, Oxford Street.  I was waiting for my elderly father who was in the disabled cubicle and might need my help; I had been there for a good while and was beginning to feel a tad self-conscious. To be honest, in such a context, I really didn't want to be engaged in conversation.  So I smiled and listened politely.

He and his wife had come to the West End to do a spot of Christmas shopping and were staying with their son who worked in London.  He told me that the son had had difficulty in finding a suitable place of worship within reasonable distance of his home in east London.  He had wanted to go to - he mentioned the name of a well-known fundamentalist conventicle in central London - but it was too far away for him to travel to on Sunday.  He had settled for a moderately distant Baptist community, having tried his local parish church and discovered that he was one of only nine people in the congregation. Nine people!  Why, in their home church back in Belfast, they could expect over 1000 worshippers on any Sunday; there were evening prayer walks, bible-reading groups - he reeled off a long list of church-related activities and services.  He did not so much rant as boast.  His sub-text: how pathetic is a church with only nine people; and how difficult it must be to be a Christian in godless London!

As he spoke, I thought about what he and I had in common.  We were both middle-aged men.  We shared a nationality and a language.  We were both Christians.  Depending on how you use the word, we were both Protestants.  Yet I felt that I was listening to someone from another planet.  This was not just because of his vast congregation (most churches in London that I know, including mine, have less than 1000 but rather more than nine people in them, despite the impression given by Rev) or even because his Christian culture and language was not my own. It was because his pride somehow resided in an expression of religious power and strength - and perhaps, given the complex context of Northern Ireland - dominance.  

I have a favourite quote the identity of whose author, I am ashamed to say, I have forgotten.  It is this: "The Church is called to be a sign of God's love in the world; not a sign of success or power".  This for me is so profoundly true, as to be almost scriptural in its status.  My work as a Christian is not to set myself, or my way of operating, above those of other Christians.  My work is to communicate God's love through Jesus Christ in my way of living, which I do alongside others, and in the context of my calling as a priest which the Church has approved and mediated.  If I do this to the best of my ability, sincerely, authentically and conscientiously, then there is a good chance others will want to live in that way.  That is how most churches grow.  But if they do not, that does not invalidate me, my ministry or my church.  A church does need a critical mass of regular and committed worshippers to survive in the long term, and tiny congregations cannot expect to be subsidised by neighbouring parishes indefinitely if they have simply given in to their own decline.  But churches which are weak and poor may nonetheless be expressions of God's love - particularly perhaps to those who are themselves weak and poor.

If the conversation had not been taking place in a public toilet, I might have asked the man why his son did not stay at his local church.  Was it because, in so small a number, he felt dispirited and unengaged?  Was it because the worship style was not familiar and/or not to his taste?  Was it because the teaching lacked authenticity or conviction?  Was it because he had no sense of the presence of God?  Was there no love? - since all these things are possible, sometimes simultaneously.  Or was it because he had stumbled upon an expression of the Christian faith which seemed weak, and he was repelled by weakness?  Because that would be an odd disposition for a follower of Christ.
 
Photo: John Lewis store, Oxford Street, London W1 showing Barbara Hepworth's sculpture: Winged Figure.  Courtesy of flickriver.com